📰BIDDEFORD | OPINION | Biddeford's Planning Failures | Part 1: Still Falling Short
By Loren McCready, Contributing Writer

November 19, 2026, Biddeford has spent years approving major development projects and making decisions that will shape the city for decades. Yet more than three years after adopting an updated Comprehensive Plan, the City still hasn't satisfied the state's requirements under Maine's Growth Management Act.
In a recent letter to the City’s Planning Department, the Maine Office of Community Affairs identified another series of deficiencies preventing the plan from being found consistent with state law. The outstanding requirements concern housing, transportation, and future land use.
Biddeford's previous comprehensive plan dates to 1999. Although the City Council adopted a replacement in 2023, multiple rounds of revisions have yet to secure a finding of state consistency. More than three years after the plan was first submitted for review, important requirements remain unfinished.
What the state is still asking:
The latest findings are worth examining in light of the amount of development Biddeford has approved in recent years.
Among the missing requirements is an estimate of how much residential and commercial development the City expects over the planning period and where it is likely to occur. The state also asks how critical natural resources will be protected from future development impacts, an important consideration given ongoing concerns about the Thatcher Brook watershed.
Transportation accounts for much of the remaining feedback. The state asks whether new subdivisions create connected neighborhoods or simply add more dead-end roads, whether sidewalks connect residents to everyday destinations, and what Biddeford expects to spend on road maintenance and improvements.
Other deficiencies include a summary of local regulations affecting affordable housing and strategies for tracking new development.
These are key considerations for a municipality experiencing significant growth. The location and design of new projects influence infrastructure costs, housing opportunities, and the financial burden residents may ultimately bear.
Biddeford has approved large developments and committed public resources to support them. The City should be able to demonstrate how those investments fit into a coordinated strategy, yet the state's findings show that important parts of that work remain unfinished.

Years of delays and a lack of accountability:
City officials have repeatedly cited staffing shortages and turnover within the Planning Department as reasons for the delays. Those challenges have undoubtedly complicated the process, but they cannot remain a sufficient explanation indefinitely.
Since first submitting the plan, Biddeford has obtained additional assistance from the Southern Maine Planning and Development Commission (SMPDC). The state has also offered guidance on addressing outstanding requirements.
Staffing changes can disrupt municipal operations, but maintaining continuity through those transitions is a responsibility of city leadership. After years of revisions and outside assistance, Biddeford still has considerable work to complete.
These delays come as city leaders confront other pressing issues. At a recent City Council workshop, members identified property taxes, overdue financial audits, infrastructure needs, and rebuilding public trust among their priorities. Councilors also expressed concerns about the pace of development and the City's financial outlook.
The Comprehensive Plan has a direct bearing on these discussions. New construction can expand the tax base, but extending roads and municipal services also brings costs that persist well beyond the initial investment. As Biddeford considers how much additional growth it can support, understanding those costs and directing development to appropriate areas should be central to its decisions.
A long-overdue responsibility:
The state has given Biddeford until February 25, 2027, to address the remaining deficiencies.
After three years of unsuccessful reviews and additional outside assistance, City Hall should be able to explain what remains unfinished, who is responsible for completing it, and how it intends to meet the deadline.
Securing a finding of state consistency should be an immediate priority, followed by implementation through zoning, infrastructure investments, and future land-use decisions.
Biddeford is facing difficult choices about its finances and capacity to support continued growth. The City's inability to complete a plan intended to guide those choices reflects a larger problem with oversight and follow-through.
Nearly three decades have passed since Biddeford's previous comprehensive-plan update. During that time, the City has undergone substantial change, with more projects already underway or under consideration.
Decisions about Biddeford's future are being made every day. The City has had years to establish a clear framework for making them. Residents should expect the next submission to finally meet the state's requirements, followed by a genuine commitment to putting the plan into practice.
WE WANT TO SHARE YOUR STORIES, OPINIONS, TIPS, NEWS, EVENTS, LETTERS, AND MORE!
SEND TO: 𝗜𝗻𝗳𝗼@𝗯𝗶𝗱𝗱𝗲𝗳𝗼𝗿𝗱𝗯𝘂𝘇𝘇.𝗰𝗼𝗺 OR





Comments